Not a single video wants to be played. · Issue #11255 · TeamNewPipe/NewPipe

submitted by Fluffgar

github.com/TeamNewPipe/NewPipe/issues/11255

Log in to comment

31 Comments

TimeNaan

Fuck YouTube for constantly doing this shit. Thank you NewPipe contributors for keeping up with it!

JeffKerman1999

Well somebody has to pay for bandwidth, and Google has enough money to bankroll the entire thing. But, you know, capitalism...

Björn Tantau

I bet they want to be played. They're just a little shy, is all.

p0wer

yeah we all get shy sometimes. it happenes

Hal-5700X , edited

Youtube mess with it's API. Wait a day or two for the frontends to fix themselves.

DeadNinja

Most Piped instances are also not working because they use NewPipe Extractor under the hood.

I have also temporarily switched to FreeTube for Android, because a few of the Invidious instances are still working fine.

The nice thing about the FOSS world is that it's pretty easy to import subscriptions and other stuff from NewPipe to FreeTube.

I hope this YouTube fuckery is handled soon. I love NewPipe way more every time it successfully deals with the YT weirdos.

Fluffgar [OP]

I wasn't even aware there was an Android version of FreeTube. It's just what I use on the PC usually.

DeadNinja

Yep, someone thought of porting the awesome Freetube app to Android. It's not as polished as NewPipe, but gets the job done. Especially at this time, it's the only one that is working, having both a local API as well as option to use Invidious API.

I pulled the apk straight from their github page via Obtainium. You may want to give it a try.

https://github.com/MarmadileManteater/FreeTubeAndroid

linearchaos

Brave mobile browser is still an option too.

tb_

Or Firefox with add-ons (on Android) instead of the browser from some crypto bro

linearchaos

This crypto bros do a REALLY good job of staying in front of YouTube ads.

I said brave because it's easy and default. If you want to get people into FF you should name plugins.

tb_

ublock origin

DarkThoughts

Yeah, same thing with Tubular. Probably a change on YT's side of things that breaks third party apps again.

Dasnap

I think the developer of SmartTube might already have a fix for their app. I haven't tested myself but people are looking happy in the Telegram channel.

Ravi

Loaded the update via the internal function a few hours ago and still got error 403 on every video I tried. Haven't twsted it thoroughly yet though.

Ravi

Installed another update, working again!

Fluffgar [OP] , edited

I saw a comment somewhere that apps using Invidious as a fallback were often still working. Have observed this to be the case for FreeTube on desktop. Though it's still hit and miss which videos want to play for some reason.

zazo

What I don't get is why spend the effort dealing with YTs shit just to increase their userbase when we should be focusing on shifting people away from YT and into decentralized solutions like PeerTube anyways?

sorrybookbroke

The people who-would shift away are users, not creators and currently the major issue with peertube is lack of content. Along with the fact that finding an instance which allows for signups and is federated with good, discoverable content is impossible currently.

I keep trying though and eventually I'm sure I'll be able to switch

WamGams

I signed up to the main instance ran by the French company. It appeared that a single video hadn't been uploaded in 2 years and I couldn't find how to see videos from other instances.

The entire service needs a redesign if people are going to switch.

NeryK

Because Google is eating the monumental costs of hosting and delivering video content. The cost of maintaining client apps is negligible in comparison. YouTube is not going anywhere unless Google deems it so, or enshittifies it enough to drive users away.

bamboo

Given their extreme efforts to monetize YouTube, I’d be surprised if it was still operating at a loss.

Praise Idleness

Because without some drastic new way to host videos, something like peertube will not replace YouTube(Framasoft agrees too). It doesn't make sense cost wise. No one can make another YouTube.

And you also get to take money from Google so win-win.

Dizzy Devil Ducky

None of the large creators, whether they're corporate or not, would ever switch over to something like PeerTube without financial incentive. Even if they did, I guarantee they'd end up killing the decentralized nature of something like PeerTube by having the largest instance and then disallowing any form of federation to ensure you are forced to their instance.

linearchaos

YouTube has essentially created a monster. Every idiot out there can upload unending amounts of super high rez footage. Even if everyone who was capable of handling their own hosting spun up a node, we'd never be able to handle 1/10 of 1% of YouTubes daily upload and that's not even mentioning the storage requirements.

The big guys aren't going to want to host over there because there's no money in it.

bruhduh

As i always said, people will go joyfully if someone can selfhost WHOLE YouTube content out there, YouTube became modern library of Alexandria while main page is shit and giggles, there's a lot of useful tutorials and education videos

vext01

I take it all the third party apps are scraping, as opposed to using an API?

nyan

The sun will freeze over before Google would give them an API.

bruhduh , edited

Libretube works fine for me, tho i usually use pipepipe and fall back to libretube and clipious in case like this

Fluffgar [OP]